While on our honeymoon, we spent some time in maui. We asked locals for the best luau, and they all recommended the Old Lahaina Luau. We stayed in Wailea, so was about an hours drive, but it was worth it. The location is gorgeous. It's specifically designed for the show, unlike hotel productions where they just set up chairs and hire a fire dancer. The food was excellent, and the history lesson they provide as each routine occurs is an added touch. The costumes are vibrant and really stand out. And the food selection is amazing. I recommend this luau if you can only choose one. It's well worth the price. Book early, as it tends to sell out.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.