If you are deciding on one boat tour or another, stop looking and book with Redline. This is the only snorkeling trip that goes to the BACK side of Molokini Crater. Amazing to look down and have hundreds of fish around you. We had Captain Andy and Kiki(I swear she was a dolphin in her former life). Don't go all the way to Maui and waste your time on a cattle call of a snorkel trip. Go 5 star with Redline. The small group allowed us to have maximum time in the water, our own space when we had spinner dolphins swimming right next to us and our very own "dolphin" KiKi, who would dive down and point out sea life such as pencil urchins, octopus, turtles, and more! The deli lunch was very good with lots of soda/juice/water to choose from. The breakfast in the morning is good as well, but if you have an appetite, bring some snacks especially if you get hungry swimming/snorkeling like I do. And you will snorkel!!! We went to 4 different spots and saw amazing sea life at all. It is a faster raft, so you get to the dive spots before the big trips come in with all the people. But, because it is a raft, it seems to be a little bouncier/rougher than a big boat. But take some Dramamine or get a Scopalomine patch from your Doctor(that is what my husband did as he gets seasick and he was FINE!) I will definitely go again and hope it is during whale season!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.