Just came back from my first trip to Hawaii/Maui. The Mana Kai was exactly what I wanted. Both my friend and I had really felt no need to stay at one of the island's big resorts that boast huge grounds with lavish swimming pool areas. Our reason for this was: if we're on a beautiful island (such as Maui) with natural, beautiful beaches, we wanted to be somewhere right on the beach with a personal, almost private feel, with easy access to walk right out to that.
The Mana Kai was exactly that. We had (and I DEFINITELY recommend having) a deluxe oceanfront room, and the view was simply phenomenal. (I will gladly e-mail anyone interested a pic of our view from the lanai.)
While the beach has suffered some errosion due to previous storms, there is still ample space to sit on the sand. The water/swimming was still really nice, and the lawn directly in front of the beach that the Mana Kai provides is completely comfortable and makes you feel like you're right on it. You really feel like you're at your own personal beach.
Our room was clean, and the kitchen was very functionable. The hotel's location, in addition to the beach, was also great: close to Wailea (shops/restaurants, etc) and in the heart of Kihei's best food, activities, etc.
I will, without a doubt, go abck to the Mana Kai.









