You get what you expect at Cary & Eddie's. Good food and good value... nothing spectacular but you leave happy. Order the combos (surf & turf). They give you "half portions" but their half portions are HUGE! I had the Rib Eye and Catch of the Day and I was one happy and satisfied customers. They have a decent dinner buffet and salad bar too. Oh, and don't forget to order a Mai Tai. Easily one of the best on the island. I didn't expect to find a great MaiTai here so that was a nice bonus. The restaurant itself and the decor are a little dated but It's nice little local dive with very friendly owners. Go check them out.
If you own or manage Hideaway Cary & Eddie's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.