My family, parents and daughter's boyfriend (who proposed while we were there), stayed in E300, a Penthouse Villa, and my husband's Aunt and her husband stayed nearby at one of the Garden Villas. Our villa overlooked the pool area on the side with two bedrooms, and the mountains on the side of the master bedroom. The lanai was facing another penthouse but you could see part of the pool area and the mountains on either side. It was absolutely gorgeous!
The elevator takes you straight into the penthouse which was great for luggage and for my mom who has a little trouble with stairs. The villas provided us with some rafts, beach chairs and umbrellas which we used at the nearby beaches. (They do run out of these so request them upon arrival.)
Beautiful rooms, a fairly large kitchen and a big dining table gave us lots of room to cook and socialize. Excellent staff that helped us out whenever we needed anything from directions to extra baking dishes for our enchiladas. The walk to the beach was a little far for my mom, but it was a nice walk for the rest of us, maybe 5-10 minutes. The pool was clean and an excellent spot to relax and take a dip. The Villas at Poi Pu are like an oasis without the hectic hustle and bustle of a hotel, but with a little community of fellow travelers who are seeking a more relaxing environment near the beach.
My husband's Aunt and her husband stayed in the Garden Villas (I don't remember which number) on the 1st floor. They were very nice inside and comfortable- although not as much of a luxury feel as the Penthouse. They are a little ways from the pool- 2 minutes. She was very happy with their villa.
We are planning on staying here again!