I guess we were just unlucky based on the other positive reviews we've seen but my husband and I each had a slice of a different type and we both disliked our pizza. To be clear, we did not order a fresh pizza. We bought slices, since it was later in the evening. I ended up throwing most of mine out. I didn't like the taste of the crust or the sauce. Perhaps it really comes down to personal preference because my review is one of the only negative reviews of this restaurant. So, if you order a slice instead of a whole pie, you might not like it. Not sure if that was the difference.
If you own or manage Hanalei Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.