This place is under new ownership and it is not as good now as it was with the old owners. They have expanded the menu then did not have everything on the menu. My steak was cooked well on the outer edge but overdone in the center. The worst part is they used to have the best cornbread around but under the new owners they did away with it and now serve a cinnamon bread... maybe it was a bad night (we were the only ones there for quite a while) but the bread was really dry and not much cinnamon flavor.
I would still recommend this place if you are in the area as even with the steak over cooked it still had good flavor and there is not a steakhouse in Laramie to eat at.
If you own or manage Old Corrall, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.