This was one of the worst dining experiences of my life and to top it all off it was also expensive. Unless you are a huge fan of animatronic pirates please do not stop here. If you are a fan of animatronic pirates I assume there is a better and cheaper place to get your fix. Ten dollar watered down drinks at least you get to keep the glass to remind you never to go there again. All you can eat does not apply to crab legs. The service was slow. The food is basically right out of your grocers freezer. 19.99 for off brand fish sticks and other foods kept warm via heat lamp. I usually can eat my food, but even I could not finish much of what I took. I should of bent over the minute I set foot on the premesis.

Every year we made this the first stop on our vacation as everyone found several things to eat.
2012 - Went this year and can't believe how bad it was! Less choices, quality very poor. Seems they are just letting the place go and not keeping it up to former standards. Save your money as there are a LOT of places to eat in the Lake Delton/Wisconsin Dells that are much better than this.

I hate seafood but my husband loves it so we went there. I was very surprised that they had lots of other stuff there so I wad not left out. And very full when we left. It was more pricey but worth what you get. And most of the food was awesome would go back.

This was a clever restaurant. The buffet was good. The pirate show really captured all of us. The only negative I could say was when I sat down at the table, there was soda all over the seat and table that had not been wiped up. That got all over my clothes and shoes. No one offered to clean it up so I had to do it myself.