I had a business dinner there on a Thursday night and quickly remembered why Eddie Martini's is considered one of the very best restaurants in the greater Milwaukee area. If you have a reservation for a specific time, they seat you then and there, no hanging around at the bar. The staff is experienced and friendly. The hostess who takes your coat as you're seated doesn't give you a coat check, she memorizies you and your coat! Food and wine are top notch. The "Ocean Martini," a giant cocktail glass filled with all manner of shellfish and seafood is a spectacular delight. Although they have a full menu, this really is primarily a steak place, and the meat is done perfectly and well seasoned. There is an extensive wine list and some wonderful desserts. Prices are not for the faint of heart, so don't go to Eddie M's if you're pinching pennies. The dining area itself is somewhat cramped and in the shape of a big "U," harking back to the days when the building housed the former "Hillside Restaurant." Doesn't bother me, my attention is what is on my plate, and what is on my plate is tough to beat.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.