The bartenders are good, the drinks are yummy, especially the after dinner ice cream drinks like a Pink Squirrel. This being our first time here we could have used a bit of guidance from the wait staff. My husband ordered the prime rib which was very good and I ordered the perch. We both got a choice of potato. My plate of perch was huge- there must have been well over 12 fillets, way too much for one person. I had leftovers for several days. The waitress could have given me a tip that it would be a huge mound of fish and told me to get a smaller portion. I had no idea. Also, while we were eating we overheard another waitress offer a diner the vegetable of the day-cauliflower. My husband and I would have liked some cauliflower or at least a vegetable. Neither of which was offered to us. I'm sure our waitress was just having an off night but it did put a damper on our meal. Otherwise it was good. We recommend it.
If you own or manage Nightingale Supper Club, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.