My husband and I really enjoy supper clubs, for the pre-dinner drinks, soups/salads, and steak and seafood. We heard about this place, which has changed hands a number of times and is under new ownership. We were the first guests of the evening on a Friday night. We were immediately impressed with the beautiful view of Lake Petenwell. We were treated to a great view of the sunset as we dined. While we could have enjoyed a nice Wisconsin fish fry we opted to order something different. No entree was more than $20, and most were priced below amounts common in this area. I ordered the scallops and the smoked gouda risotto, and hubby had NY Strip. No salad bar, but choice of soup or salad. Hubby had clam chowder and I had french onion soup. They say all items but two are made from scratch. We were very happy. The NY Strip was the best we have had in Central WI, and the scallops were good as was the risotto - although very rich. We would definitely go back. You can't beat the price nor the view. We did not note any problems that some other reviewers have shared - place was clean, staff was very friendly, and we were charged appropriately. Can't wait to go back with a group of friends for dinner, or Sunday bloody marys, or for lunch. If you go on a Friday or Saturday night, go early or be ready to wait.
If you own or manage Dirty Oar Supper Club, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.