My wife and I like Libby's. We eat at Libby's eight to 10 times per year. However, it is not the first place we think of when eating out in Mequon. The food is above average and the service is very friendly; however, the place is cold in the winter and the dining romm feels like a barn. It also is at an odd price point. We tend to be somewhat frugal for our everyday dining, and while it is not expensive, it is also not cheap. When we go out for a nicer occasion, we bypass Libby's for better and more expensive places.
One posiive for Libby's is that it serves dinner on Mondays. That can be hard to find.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.