I am not a coffee drinker myself, though my wife travels weekly throughout the States, and when at our weekend house, The Coffee Mill is her pick. We have ways of making coffee at home (French Press, brewer, etc.) but when I bring back coffee from the Coffee Mill all is good. She likes the flavor, and that its not as acidic as Starbucks.
On the other side of the Lake is a Caribou (2nd favorite) and also a Starbucks.
Since I usually am the fetcher of said coffee, the staff (and I believe Owner) that I see each week are great, always friendly and chatty.
If you own or manage The Coffee Mill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.