We came here for what ended up being brunch/lunch. They only give reservations to their guests (those staying at the Inn) and we were warned to come early as there were usually long waits. This was true. We were given a pager and told it would be about 1 hour. It was probably just under 1 hour.
My husband ordered the award winning cherry stuffed french toast. He said it was out of this world. I ordered the cherry coffee cake. I asked how big it was and the waitress replied "It would fit on that saucer". Well, she should have shown me how tall it was! Yes, it fit on the saucer, but if It'd known it was like 4 inches tall I would not have ordered the cherry pancakes too! As it was, I ate the pancakes (they were exceptional) and got a box for the coffee cake. I enjoyed every last bite of that cake over the next day.
Very reasonable prices for excellent food. Definitely worth the wait.
If you own or manage White Gull Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.