3.5* I'm a local who wasn't crazy about this place the first few times I tried it. Other local places offer more affordable options, but I found a winner in PJ's deep dish pizza - the crust is crunchy and chewy, the ingredients fresh and, best of all, the pie isn't greasy!
Beware, PJ's isn't cheap and your wallet will take a blow ($17 for a large one-topping deep dish), especially if you're feeding the family. But with all the cheap, sub par pizza offerings it is a great option if you are willing to pay for quality ingredients. That being said, I am not impressed with the pasta, subs and most of the appetizers. Especially with local Pipitone's down the street, which offers great subs, pasta and appetizers at a much better price.
If you own or manage Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.