When you get inside you do get the feel of an old style diner. It is cozy, with both booth and counter seating. Service was fast and the cook making the burgers does it right in front of everyone. He does very well with the limited space he has to work in. The cook working the day I was in was very responsible to make sure the food came out right. Also the burgers are hand pattied not a frozen burger so that makes them taste better than a lot of places right there. The portions were just right.
Overall it enjoyed my experience and felt the price was inline for the food I was served. I would go back again next time I am in Baraboo.