It was our first trip to the Island and we loved it. The views are amazing but make sure you book a place to stay early enough. We waited till last minute and we were lucky to find something. Stayed at treehouse 1 and it was really peaceful nestled in the woods. Get gas before going on the Island cause the gas Station is only open 2 days a week and the marina has only 1 pump. Also if you want to bring any food across buy it on the mainland (especially when you have kids). The grocery store is expensive but has all the necessities. Boat Tours are expensive and book ahead. We prefered the town park over the state Park. The Beach is awesome and you can rent kayaks and boats for cheap.
If you own or manage Madeline Island, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.