We ate here last week on our trip down to SC. It is conveniently located across the plaza parking lot from the La Quinta Inn where we stayed (awesome!!!). That's about the only positive. Not sure why all the great reviews. Interior seemed dirty and dingy, definitely outdated. However, I can easily overlook an outdated decor if a restaurant is clean and has good food and service. Unfortunately this is not so at La Carreta. When we were being led to our table, we passed by several other empty tables that still hadn't been cleared (and never were while we were there). Also, there were straw wrappers and little paper napkin roll holders here and there on the floor. Clearly they'd fallen off tables and nobody bothered to pick them up. Additionally, several times I saw employees chatting and laughing at a back counter as if they had nothing better to do. Our waiter was ok (he was efficient and did his job well enough..just not overly friendly...although it could have been because it seemed like he was the only one doing any work?!). The Margaritas were ho hum and the food just mediocre. Next time we drive through Summersville we are going to El Patron (or it might be called Mi Patron). I would skip this restaurant.
If you own or manage La Carreta Mexican Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.