My wife and I stayed in the Fall Cottage for our 2nd Wedding Anniversary. Cottage is definitely the way to go. We had some problems getting the jets to work in the hot tub but other than that the stay was great. Breakfast was fantastic. Beautiful grounds. Would recommend this to a friend and would definitely go back for another stay.
Make sure to plan ahead for dinner though as the chef needs sufficient notice to include you in the evening dinner. If you do not want to participate, still plan ahead since you are 4 miles outside of town and there are no other options.