So, having escaped nearby Half Moon Bay bar and grill, we moved over to Bennett's. Pretty basic menu items. We ordered the clam chowder, an order of fish and chips with two extra pieces of fish, and a crab cheddar melt sandwich. We planned on sharing, so the extra fish. Wow. The sandwich arrived perfect, but the fish meal was short. Bringing this to the order takers attention, she promptly brought not the one piece we were missing, but two huge portions of fish. Note here, although it's typical for us to order extra, this was not necessary, as the meals were large to begin with. Now as to the quality......the crab sandwich was perfect in every way. A huge portion of crab salad, perfectly seasoned, with I think some chopped green onions? and grilled so the cheese was melted just right. Next time I won't share. The fish was nice and thick, not paper thin like some seafood chain restaurants. It was beer battered just right, not greasy, and served with pretty ordinary fries . Excellent customer service. I hope this place lasts.
If you own or manage Bennett's Fish Shack, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.