I debated how many dots to give this one and finally decided on 4 with the caveat that this is based on the type of establishment it is which is a cafe and bar. We stopped in after a ride for a beverage and found ourselves having the chowder which was billed as award winning. I believe it! The chowder was creamy without being paste-like. There were lovely chunks of potato and sweet salty bacon but more than anything else there was a bounty of fresh local clam chunks that were still perfectly tender. Amazing. We tried some of the fresh shooters made from the local oysters. Yes, wonderful. Then sampled the coconut shrimp. Still tasty and above average because the sweet chili sauce served with it had a wonderful balance of sweet and heat. Pricing was more than fair and the selection of beverages was good. Definitely worth a try.
If you own or manage Castaways Seafood Grille, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.