We tried to eat at this place twice, unsuccessfully, and succeeded only on the third try. The lunch hours are so idiosyncratic that you may as well assume it is closed. Dinner ends at 9:30 on a Friday, and that is the "late night" extended hours. Yes, this is a small town on an island and all that, but a bit longer hours and predictability would be great.That said, the food was delicious. We had small plates; each was very well prepared. Service was kind and helpful but not intrusive or overbearing. Decor is comfortable, and the tables on the porch have a good, relaxing view of the water.Definitely would try to go there again, just not sure how easy it would be to fit it into the cramped schedule of a weekend break at the island.
If you own or manage New Leaf Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.