We came for lunch after a few years' absence. We had fond memories of the food and wanted to revisit it. It was a sunny day, so we sat on the patio, which was very pleasant. The server was friendly and helpful. Vegetarian and Gluten-Free items are clearly labeled on the menu. The food was good, and tasted fresh. Lunch for two (a sandwich and a half sandwich-soup combo; no drinks) came to $25. The bookshop next door is perfect for an after-lunch browsing session.
If you own or manage Colophon Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.