Go for the pizza - since what makes for a good or even great pizza is highly debatable and often a personal choice, I won't claim it is the best in Winchester, but it is very good, with a crisp crust that yields to become chewy, a good sauce with it's own flavor and well blended toppings. The atmosphere is a bit odd, as many have noted, with the indoor outdoor seating in the mall entrance way, and wines are average for a pizza place, but we have not had a bad meal. The pasta we have had ranges from good to very good, with good salads and antipasto.
Take time to drop in at Gabriel Brothers at the other end of the strip (the inside of the small mall is a second-run movie theater and gym) and rummage through the seconds and overruns of clothing and shoes to find a $50 gem selling for $5-10.
If you own or manage Umberto's Pizza and Pasta, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.