Stayed Oct 21-23 with my wife, on way to Skyline Dr. and Luray. Researched all area hotels, this one was consistently highly rated. It lived up to its high rating. Would bring my wife here again. This is a great value hotel. By that I mean not a lot of 5 star frills (don't expect live music in lounge, luxurious towels, monogrammed luxurious robes, expensive lotions, or a bathtub--stand up shower only). But, don't confuse it with cheap, flea-bag places. It's not. Thought it was better than lower-rated, in town hotels in Winchester proper or Front Royal.
Do expect very new feeling, modern hotel (although cookie cutter styling) that's absolutely clean, excellent maid service, basic, but spotless rooms with small refrig, microwave, coffeemaker, soft but comfortable bed, bright safe parking right down and outside your window so you can see your car, nothing around area to attract derelicts to parking lot, convenient, off-highway location, IHOP for breakfast two minutes away (hotel restaurant breakfast not included), easy check in and typical, expedited check out (invoice left under door just leave your key in room), free coffee bar in lobby. Pretty quiet outside room, only heard a few people briefly walk by. They apparently separated us from folks there for a wedding. Smart move--never heard it. I got government rate (state employee) so hotel was super cheap.
I liked how General Mgr. responded on Tripadvisor to most of the reviews, good or bad--shows attention to detail and personal involvement, which was reflected in overall way hotel presented itself. Good job!
Now, if I was forced to find fault, the cons, and these are really minor: No bathtub, but at less than 80 bucks a night, I'll stand, and the shower was huge and, of course, spotless, with hot water strong and plentiful. Relatively loud heating unit (this thing could heat a factory if you cranked up the temperature on the remote, digital wall control), even on low, the fan sounded pretty strong. Not broken sounding, just strong. This was not too terrible though and we slept fine.
Staff: young woman at check-in was pleasant enough and efficient. Met maintenance man in elevator and chit-chatted. Pleasant guy, seemed genuinely happy, Talked to him about Skyline Dr. and he told us of his awesome view from the roof. Only minor complaint is that the rest of the lobby staff barely looked up and didn't give any greetings, even though they're located directly in from the door, when we went in and out (and anyone else entering or leaving). A little "good morning" greeting, or "have a nice day" is expected, especially when you pretty much walk right by them--especially in Virginia. Without it, it makes staff seem standoff-ish.
Again, if that was all that was wrong with this hotel--book it! You will be glad you did.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
October 31, 2011
Dear atown1,
Thank you so much for your wonderful comments regarding your stay with us. Thank you as well for the kind comments regarding my responses, I do make it a point to respond to all reviews as I do firmly believe in letting all reviewers know that my entire staff and I genuinely appreciate the comments about our hotel, good and bad, so we can always improve.
I will definitely make it a point to let our Front Desk staff know that first impressions are lasting impressions, and we should greet all guests with a warm smile and greeting,whether they are coming or going.
We look forward to seeing you again in your return trip to the Winchester area and staying with us again.
Regards,
Bill Knowles
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.