My boyfriend and I stayed at the Bentley Manor Inn for two nights when we visited Colonial Williamsburg. The Inn was amazing from the room to the breakfast to the management. Fred and Jane, the innkeepers, were friendly, professional, and just lovely people. The Inn is beautifully decorated with everything freshly painted and perfectly matched. As the Inn is only 1-2 years old, it's charming, but not falling apart in any way, and everything works.
Breakfast is served from 8:30-9:30 am and when we arrived downstairs each morning we found a lovely table set for us. Breakfast started off with orange/cranberry juice and some fruits with yogurt and granola on top. During our two breakfasts we were offered a choice of: blueberry pancakes, cinnamon raisin french toast, eggs any way including omelets, fresh biscuits, and sausage. Everything was scrumptious. During breakfast we were able to talk to Fred and Jane about the best sights to see in Williamsburg - they were friendly and very helpful. We especially liked Revolutionary City at Colonial Williamsburg, which we found out about thanks to them. Each day after returning from sightseeing, we found bottles of water and homemade chocolate chip cookies waiting for us.
We loved our room (the Thomas Jefferson) and there are some that are even nicer. Check the pictures we've posted. The bed was extremely comfortable and the room was beautiful. The bathroom was normal size - definitely not cramped - and we had no complaints at all.
In short, we wholeheartedly recommend the Bentley Manor Inn for a wonderful stay in Williamsburg.