I give Mamacita's 2 stars because when we ordered drinks, my buddy's girlfriend had chips of glass in her piña colada. (Noticed after the first sip) It took about 10 mins for the server to give her another drink, mind you it was not crowded at all. You would also think the replacement drink would be on the house. I don't expect things for free but, that was deserving of a free drink or some type of discount. The prices were comparable to other restaurants of that type on the island, but the food and/or portions were not. It was the only disappointing experience we had in Culebra.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.