This is our favorite place for lunch when near Middleburg. It is definitely worth the drive. No, they don't cater to fads, anything or anyone. We like that. The owner is a great guy, often coming out and giving treats to children who are with their parents. Sure, a couple of the folks taking your order can be surly at times. But the sandwiches, homemade cookies and pies make up for that. Also, lthere is a a great outdoor patio out back. Also indoor seating out back in a carriage house. No, it is nothing fancy. Very laid back. Beat up but comfortable tables and chairs with umbrellas. Very peaceful. If you want fancy, you can get fancy nearby - at the Salamander Café down the street (owners of the Salamander Inn). You will also pay big bucks for that fancy. We don't think the food is nearly as good as the Upper Crust. The Upper Crust is all homemade and tastes like something your grandmother in the Midwest would have cooked up. Go out and support this local business that has been serving good food to the community since 1980. It is where the locals go. Highly recommend.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.