I've been to Andy's, at least, 20 times, and the food's always been good. People are friendly, you can eat outside, and there's an oddly-underutilized bar in the basement. Restaurant food's gotten really expensive in the past 5 years, but Andy's standard Italian/Greek fare is priced right, and their pizza's right there with other good non-chain pizza.
Can't give 5 stars, though, because they've screwed up an order of mine more than once (once the wrong toppings -- once forgot to make order).
If you own or manage Andy's A Taste of the Mediterranean, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.