Unfriendly bald old men as hosts. First strike. The waitress looked like she just woke up from a nap. We experienced extremely slow service from start to finish. Actually, the waitress was really quick in grabbing our payment at the end, but that's about the fastest we saw her move the entire night. Food was mediocre. I could have cooked a better steak at home. The full rack of lamb was only 4 ribs of meat. The sides were clearly prepped way ahead of time and the cheese on the potato was crusty and tasted like cafeteria food. I'm not sure what all the rave is about. Oh, and it's way over priced. Never going back again. Try Lightfoot or Vintage 50 for better service and food.
If you own or manage Tuscarora Mill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.