After a morning chasing around bathroom cabinets and lawn furniture, i was hungry. Both the Chief of Staff and I had heard about Jimmy's so we decided to track it down and give it a try. It was about 1:30pm, so we missed whatever lunch rush there was.
The bar/restaurant was clean and well maintained. The decor was "Sports Bar-Modern" with a big chunk of patriotic memorabilia. There were a wide variety of seats, tables and booths in the bar and separate dining areas.
The CoS selected a Roast Beef on Weck and I got an open-faced roast beef sandwich. Alternate sides weren't a problem and service was prompt and courteous. The menu had a wide selection of dishes, mostly bar-food but some other entrees as well. The food was good. Not great but a solid good. Serving sizes were lunch appropriate. And the cost was reasonable. ($30 for two meals, a beer and tip) Most entrees were under $10.
Evidently the bar features live music on the weekends.
Parking is in a municipal lot about a block away. Jimmy's faces a side street rather than the Elden Street main drag. So it would be easy to miss if you didn't know exactly where you were going.
I get the feeling Jimmy's is trying to lock down a niche in the growing Herndon demographic. I wouldn't hesitate to go back or to recommend Jimmy's, but I wouldn't go out of my way to go back either.
If you own or manage Jimmy's Old Town Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.