My husband and I love this place! This is the first restaurant we went to after we came back from our honeymoon to Italy - that should tell you something :)
We debate on whether Pomodoro's or Ciro's has the better pizza - but they're too close to call, and their pizza really is amazing. As is their pasta - love the chicken parm and the gnocchi. The only downside to the place is that sometimes seating is a bit hard to find, if you go there during the height of dinner. However - it's worth it, even if you have to wait for a table to open up! We've never waited more than 10 minutes! (This is an order at the counter, find your own table kind of place.)
I'm one of those people who doesn't really like salt (I never add salt to anything) - so if you are also not big on salt, make sure to let them know when you order - as they can make the sauce less salty for you in most dishes!
They are consistently great - if you're craving great NY-Italian, this is the place to go!
If you own or manage Pomodoro, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.