WOW! First visit...heard a lot about it...all good. I'd say GREAT ! So....the selection and presentation speak volumes just walking in! It is bright, cheery, and has something for everyone...this is rare and admirable. Explore even further and you find a menu that I don't think anyone on this island can beat. The ingredients in the salad and sandwich we had were so fresh and artfully done to boot !! These folks know what they're doing. What a breath of fresh air. AND they are friendly, even though it was a bit crowded when we got there. I've seen people say they are pricey....are you kidding me?....you TOTALLY get what you pay for. If anything, it is underpriced for the quality products they offer.Roast turkey and beef right out of the oven, fresh sides.....your lunch made to order...I'd wait for that! They have raised the bar....thank goodness. The best mix of wines and beers, cheeses.....at last...wonderful cheeses...premium deli meats...I mean when/where have you ever been able to get REAL mortadella? We are totally hooked....our go to place for sure. LOVE IT !
If you own or manage Poseidon's Pantry Gourmet Grocery & Deli, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.