We visited on an evening when there was no crowd and it took us a few minutes to decide on what we wanted as there is so much from which to choose! I cannot imagine how crazy it must be when it's crowded.....with lots of folks having trouble deciding from all those choices. Once we did decide, though, and got our treats, we were very happy with them. The staff was very friendly and prices were average for the type of items offered. We would go there again if we are in the area.
If you own or manage Island Creamery, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.