One night after dinner we wanted ice cream and headed for Island Creamery. Unfortunately the parking lot was jammed, so instead of waiting for a spot we headed to Muellers instead. The "world famous" peach sundae was spectacular, with fresh peaches and real homemade whipped cream, but I was disappointed to find that they were serving Turkey Hill ice cream. Being from PA, I get Turkey Hill ice cream on a regular basis, and it is good, but I expected that the stuff here would be locally made. Prices would have been reasonable for locally made stuff but were a little high for factory produced ice cream. Atmosphere is great.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.