I'm from St. J, and Anthony's has gone through several owners. It used to be great (best burgers and milkshakes around!) but I've been really disappointed with it since I moved back to town. My husband and I live around the corner, and we were looking forward to having such a good diner close by. Based on our experiences I don't think we will ever go there again. The breakfast we had with a friend was just not good (rubbery eggs, basic home fries) and extortionately expensive for the area. We recently moved here from NYC, and our breakfast at Anthony's cost us what it would have in Manhattan... crazy! We've been for dinner twice and both times the fries have been so soggy as to be inedible and the sandwiches and soups basic at best (and again, Manhattan prices). Sorry Anthony's, but we're not coming back.
If you own or manage Anthony's Diner, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.