We spent a few nights last summer at the Four Columns. We love the village and it's a good place to use as home base for a couple of days of exploration on back roads to see various museums and historic spots, not to mention scenery.
The food in the dining room is really excellent, as other reviewers have pointed out. Really fresh ingredients and clear flavors. It sounds ridiculous to rave about a tomato mozarella salad but the one we had at the Four Columns set the gold standard. We ate another night at the Old Newfane Inn. That was very different, more old world (1950's real French or continental cuisine) but also excellent.
Our room at Four Columns was nice. Beautiful view onto the village. I found the humongous bathroom sort of odd but others might it find it cool. It was very thoughtful that they offer free long distance in place of cell phone reception. They also do free faxes.
The only discordant note and it is the reason I won't give this inn the top rating is that our smoke detector started beeping about 11 one night. It was the kind of intermittent beep that happens when a battery gets low but in fact this was a hard wired unit. I called the front desk and after getting no reply went down to the dining area. The owner who was closing up said, "Oh, I thought we fixed that. I thought we disconnected it. Well, I don't know what I can do now so why don't you move across the hall to an empty room (inferior room) and sleep there." He didn't even say he was sorry. The issue was that we still would have heard the beep from across the hall. Because we are handy, we stood on a chair and thoroughly disconnected the unit ourselves. We told the owner in the morning and again he didn't say he was sorry...and he didn't seem worried at all that his guests had created a major building code violation. He did offer to buy us around of drinks or a bottle of wine that night in the dining room but the waiter didn't know anything about the it that evening and the owner was not there so we didn't push it. We have friends who are New England inn-keepers and they have fast learned to be handy men and women with a rudimentary knowledge of the basics of electrical work and plumbing. Maybe this guy will grow into it. He has a very pretty, well-situated property. But for country inns to earn five stars, they need to concentrate on the details.




