I've been to Middlebury a few times now to visit my daughter who's attending Middlebury College. I've dined at several places in town where my daughter has suggested but none compare with Morgan's Tavern at the Middlebury Inn. The restaurant lists an average dinner as being from $16-42 but we had a light entree (chicken piccatta) and a glass of hosu wine for $16 which was very satisfying. The atmosphere could use a little work not that it's dirty or anything. I just think that they could have designed the dining room a little differently. But the food and service are top notch. Gloria (our bartender) sure knows how to make a cocktail.
I would recommend both the Middlebury Inn and Morgan's Tavern for the best that Middlebury has to offer.
If you own or manage Morgan's Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.