My wife and I came to the island to visit my parents and was told that this was the best restaurant on the island. While the restaurant does not take reservations, the wait was well worth it. My wife had the garlic-jalapeno tilapia which was very tender and delicious and I had the pasta carbonara. I have been to Italian restaurants before and had a similar item but none compare to the meal I had that night. Even though we had our fill, we decided to splurge and got the desert sampler which includes a cannoli, a slice of tiramisu, chocolate cake, and cheesecake as well as spumoni ice cream. Each portion of the desert was amazing! The service was the only negative that I experienced while there. Our waitress was very kind but with the number of people there, it took some time for her to make her rounds.
If you own or manage Gabriella's Italian Grill & Pizzeria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.