We went twice in the last few years. One was pretty good, the other not so (and unfortunately that time was our anniversary!) The food wasn't bad, but it was over-priced. To tell you the truth, I have neither pleasant or disappointed memories..I simply forgot about the dinner, other than the price.
The atmosphere, on the other hand, can be really good. On the deck, in the evening, when it's hopping, and the experience is more about being on vacation. We sat inside one evening last year when the weather was too hot, and it was definitely not the same.
If you own or manage Castaways Seafood and Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.