The kids were fascinated with watching the potters at Pigeon River Pottery. Prices there were not outrageous. The shop in the old mill is pretty cool. There's a pretty good photo op spot for the old mill, although there's not much room for someone to stand in the foreground (sidewalks only) to get the old mill in the background.
If you own or manage Old Mill Square, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.