The people at the Caledonian were among the friendliest and most helpful we found in Scotland. The best thing about the Caledonian is that it is in the middle of Portree, a very nice harbor city on the Isle of Skye where a "town" is defined as any community with more than one crofters house and a herd of sheep. The bedroom itself was large and looked out on the lovely Portree harbor. The furnishings were old and worn to some extent but very clean. The beds were adequate but comfortable. My wife who is a very sensitive sleeper had her best night's sleep at the Caledonian. A number of restaurants and shops are right out the front door. I had the best fish and chips meal of my life at a small restaurant on Harbor row - The Lower Deck.

Arrived in Portree late on a Saturday afternoon - like other reviewers tried elsewhere and eventually found the Caledonian. From the outside, it really didn't look anything great. How wrong could we be? What a find! Room was very clean and comfortable - furnishings are relatively new as is the decor. Staff are very helpful and polite and genuinely endeavour to make sure you enjoy your stay. The entertainment in the bar was great (very popular with the locals) - best night we've had in a long time! Really good value - £70 for bed and full cooked breakfast with toast and orange juice. Will definitely be back again soon - next time for longer.

Tried more expensive hotels but no vacancies so settled for the Urquhart Caledonian. First impression from outside was slightly worrying but once inside could not have been happier with choice. Full marks for everything. I could not recommend it highly enough. Food, rooms, cleanliness, helpful, friendly staff and situation, all top marks. We will definitely be back.

I have NO IDEA what was going on with that last reviewer. We had a lovely stay June 23-25. It was one of our favorite hotels of the entire trip. The service was warm and friendly; and the room was very comfortable and roomy with a nice view. The location was ideal. I would stay here again in a heartbeat! (And we enjoyed the breakfasts very much.) Another nice touch was the tea service and cookies left in the room each day. We so enjoyed spreading out in that room and looking out at the water. We spent more time in the room than we normally would have because it was so pleasant.