We have tried every pizza place on the island, and this is it. We LOVE this pizza! We always order the original...simple mozzarella, which is just perfect, but I have had the BLT pizza and some friends had something with figs...they loved it ! the BLT is really wonderful, we will order for sure when the weather warms up and we are craving fresh food. But for now, when it is cold, and we want healthy comfort food...Paulie's pizza is it. Not greasy, perfect crust, and a super fresh sauce that is just right. Mmmmmm, mmm good! We do worrry as the restaurant is often empty, but we have a small child, so often eat far too early to be social, so hopefully they are busy enough to keep in business. If you are a visitor to HHI, skip the nasty delivery, Call in an order togo for Paulies, and you will not be disapointed!
If you own or manage Paulie's Coal Fired Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.