We just spent two weeks in Garden City and visited Garden City Pizza several times (since the snack bar at our condo building right next door was rarely open). My 17 year old became addicted to the chicken wings, he said they were the best he has ever had. I loved the garlic bread (which was pizza dough baked with garlic all over it and brushed again with garlic when it came out of the oven, yummy). The service was a bit slow sometimes because there was only one person working (he said the other one was running late) but it was always friendly and the food was made right in front of us, so we know it was fresh. The prices on some things were good, the chicken wings were pretty expensive ($9 for 12 wings).
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.