I have been to Cellar on many occasions for girls nights (hello wine specials), and on a date night. The food has always been stellar, except for the pizza that is just okay. They change their menu seasonally which when you fall in love with a dish like the duck quesadilla it can be heart breaking, but they do have some regulars like the lobster mac and cheese. I'm hoping they'll keep the chicken sausage and mushroom tart i had the other night because my friend and I both wanted more, and almost got into a fight over the last morsel. Manners are lost when good food is on the line. Their downfall is the size of the space and the limited seating. It can get crowded during peak times, making it hard to keep up a conversation with your dinner partner, but on the other side people watching can be just as fun if your date is dull.
If you own or manage Cellar on the Greene, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.