Fulton Five was a true experience, the building itself is beautiful and tucked away enough to feel like your own secret place. The hostess made us feel very welcome upon our arrival. The ambiance was elegant but comfortable. The only minor drawback is that the bar area should be more separate from the dinning area because it was too loud as some other reviewers noted.
Our server was knowledgeable, efficient, and friendly. He even took our picture for us when we asked so we could remember our special birthday dinner.
For our appetizer we ordered the insalate di funghi aka mushroom salad and it was very good, simple like Italian food should be so the ingredients could shine. It was so hard to choose just one thing because everything sounded great. For our meals, he had a tortellini with lamb meat and I had several bites and it was wonderful, he said the best pasta he's ever had; I had the special pasta for the day which was tortellini also with duck confit and cauliflower in duck broth and it was heavenly! This is the real deal.
I chose Tiramisu for my birthday dessert and they lit me a candle which was special. =]
It was very good and a sharable large portion.
Definitely a five star experience and we will be back I'm sure.
If you own or manage Fulton Five, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.