We have been there numerous times. it is great to sit out on the lawn with martini before dinner. The service, drink and view were spectacular. we went in for dinner and it was all down hill. the food and service were terrible. we selected price fix with 2 small appetizers, entre and dessert. we sent back 1 appetizer, both entries and did not even bother to complain about the desssert. since it was price fix there was not much they would do as far as taking off $ but they took some off. that is not the point you go to enjoy and not get an attitude or terrible food. Talking to others we met around the island there were additional complaints so we were not the only ones having a bad experience. The worst was the fish - sent it back because it was over cooked then they sent it to the table 98% raw they wanted to try again but who would. We will go again but only sit outside for martini then head out elsewhere
If you own or manage Atlantic Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.