While attending a wedding on Block Island, we stayed 2 nights at the Hygeia House. After spending nearly $200 per night, we were extremely disappointed. The house had a lovely antique feel about it in general. The linens in the bathroom were frayed and there was no bath mat. The bed was lumpy and the room was small. The breakfast was the most disappointing. On the second day, there wasn't even the fruit salad as there had been the day before. The baked goods all seemed to be store bought, and very mediocre. The kitchen, off the dining room, was a mess. Although the staff was not rude, they were not overly welcoming either.
On a positive note, the location was good. We were able to walk everywhere. The porch and yard were great for hanging out.
For the same price, I have stayed elsewhere and gotten much more for my money. Although I feel the Hygeia House could be spiffed up, I think they should begin improving the breakfast.

Beautiful view and breezes from our room. The house is very old and authentic looking. Our bed dipped a little in the middle and the room smelled a little funky if you shut the windows but other than that no complaints. The owner was friendly and helpful. The breakfast was delicious...homemade berry muffins, fruit, bagels, fresh coffee, juice. Old dog named Brother that roamed the lower level...gave the place even more character :D We sat on the huge front porch in rocking chairs watching the sun set and enjoying the breeze. Lovely place to stay.

Location, location, location!!! And gorgeous views! I loved the story of the renovation, and the family names for each of the unique rooms--Hygeia House feels steeped in history, yet the vibe is comfortable, relaxing, and laid-back. We used Hygeia House as a central location from which to explore the island on our bikes. Host Lisa helped with recommendations about what to see and do on the island. My one regret is that I did not have enough time to peruse the poetry and literary artifacts on display in the house, but even that has a silver lining--I will need to come back again!!!

My kids and I enjoyed a long weekend here in September. Our room was perfect for a family - two bed rooms and on the lower level so we didn't bother others with our noise. Breakfast was good and filling. The atmosphere was very cordial and friendly. My kids loved Brother the golden retriever. The only consideration for a family- my sense is that the place is more for retorted and couples. We were the only family there and felt a little out of place.