Worthy of consideration for a Michelin Star (very good in its class). We've been there several times before this. I hate the parking situation in West Chester, but we had a 6 P.M. seating and found a spot near the front door. Had a reservation (don't think of showing up without one) and were seated at once. BYOB. Very attentive servers, but dressed in jeans. I don't think that level of attire is appropriate in a place of this caliber. Noise level was comfortable, and the place was packed. There were 6 of us. I wouldn't call us foodies, but we understand fine dining. The menu offers a Giro Del Menue (tour of the menu) which includes half portions of an appetizer, pasta, main dish and dessert at a fixed price. Everyone at the table must order the Giro, but each person can order whichever items he/she likes. It's not the case that everyone eats the same meal, like some restaurants which offer a tasting menu, and everyone gets the same dishes. All 6 of us had the Giro. Everyone had nothing but praises. No complaints about small portions either. My advice? Take the tour.
If you own or manage Avalon Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.