If you've heard of Gullifty's, you've no doubt heard about their desserts, and rightly so. They've had the best dessert in the Pittsburgh area for years now - from decadent cakes to tart pies and everything in between. However, I would recommend going elsewhere for dinner. While they don't serve bad food, per se, it's a little...off. The sauce on their Reuben isn't quite right. The fries are just a tiny bit undercooked. While the place excels at desserts, they can't seem to get the combination of flavors down for their dinner/lunch fare.
That said, it has improved over the years, and it's always worth checking in to see if they've gotten the hang of dinner yet. And to eat their Key Lime Pie.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.